Buying a property

How much to offer on a house, including one that needs work

The asking price is where the seller starts, not what the house is worth. How to research sold prices, set your maximum before you negotiate, work out an offer on a house that needs work from the cost of the work, and put your offer in writing.

Before you offer: the asking price, what similar homes sold for and your offer still to decide
Contents

Key points

  • Base your offer on evidence: sold prices of similar homes, the property's condition, how long it has been on the market and local demand.
  • The HomeOwners Alliance says that in a buyer-friendly market an opening offer 5% to 10% below the asking price may be reasonable, but some homes justify an offer much closer to it (November 2026).
  • Decide your maximum before you negotiate, from the full cost of buying and any work the house needs, not from the asking price.
  • For a house that needs work, price the work from a survey and quotes, then check the asking price has not already allowed for it before you take it off your offer.
  • In England, Citizens Advice says a written offer is always made subject to contract; in Scotland an offer is made through a solicitor and becomes binding once missives are concluded.

How much should you offer on a house?

How much to offer on a house depends on evidence, not a fixed percentage: sold prices of similar homes, the property's condition, its time on the market and local demand. The HomeOwners Alliance says an opening offer 5% to 10% below the asking price may be reasonable in a buyer-friendly market, while some homes justify offering close to it.

Before you pick a number, decide the most you will pay, based on the full cost of buying and any work the house needs. This guide covers the research, how to set that maximum, how to work out an offer on a house that needs work, and how to make the offer so it is taken seriously.

Research before you offer

The asking price tells you what the seller hopes for. It is not a valuation. The HomeOwners Alliance (updated 12 November 2026) quotes Jeremy Leaf, a former RICS Residential Chair, calling it "an aspirational starting price" that "doesn't necessarily reflect what the property is worth."

Gather this evidence before you decide:

EvidenceWhere to find itWhat it tells you
Sold prices of similar homes nearbyHM Land Registry price data on GOV.UK (England and Wales)What buyers actually paid, not what sellers asked
Asking prices of similar homes for saleProperty listingsThe competition the seller faces
Time on the market and price reductionsListing history, the agentHow keen the seller may be to agree
Condition and work neededYour viewings, a survey, quotesWhat the house will cost you on top of the price
Demand for this type of homeThe agent, how fast similar homes sellHow much competition you may face
Your own positionYour budget and timescaleWhat makes your offer attractive

Tip

Compare like with like. A sold price is only useful if the home was similar in size, condition, outside space and location, and sold recently. Note the differences, because they are what you will use to explain your offer.

Our guide to comparing the houses you have viewed shows how to line properties up against the same priorities, and our questions to ask when viewing a house include the ones that tell you why it is for sale and for how long.

How much below the asking price to offer

There is no rule. The HomeOwners Alliance gives 5% to 10% below the asking price as a reasonable opening offer in a buyer-friendly market, and says you may have more room if the property has been for sale a long time, needs work or competes with many similar homes. It also warns that the asking price may already reflect those things.

Two broad approaches, both described by the HomeOwners Alliance:

  1. Start lower and negotiate. You are less likely to overpay, but you should expect to negotiate, and your offer needs evidence behind it.
  2. Go in with your best offer. Useful where you expect strong competition, and required where the agent asks for sealed bids.

Watch out

A very low offer with nothing behind it can backfire. The HomeOwners Alliance quotes Jeremy Leaf warning that it can alienate the seller, so that even a better second offer is ignored. Explain how you reached your figure.

How to work out your maximum offer

Costs & spending in Mekozo, close up: whole project £8,300 plus one unpriced item, paid £2,000, still to pay £3,500, £12,000 in the plan

Mekozo's Costs & spending view adds the buying costs and the work the house needs to one total, with what is not yet priced flagged, so you can see your real total before you make an offer.

Try it free for 30 days, no card needed

Your maximum is the most you will pay before walking away. Set it before you speak to the agent, from your total budget rather than the asking price:

LineWhat goes in it
Total budgetAll the money available for buying, moving and the work
Less: buying costsTax, legal fees, survey, agent fees where the buyer pays, registration
Less: moving costsRemovals, overlap of bills, storage
Less: essential workWork the house needs to be safe, dry and usable, from quotes where possible
Less: contingencyA separate allowance for what the survey and opening up reveal
Equals: the most you can pay for the houseYour walk-away figure

Then compare that figure with the evidence. If sold prices suggest the house is worth less than your maximum, that is your ceiling. If it is worth more, your maximum still stands: paying more means less for the work, or borrowing from the contingency.

Our list of the costs of buying a house covers every buying cost, including the hidden ones. Keep those costs separate from the price, so a higher offer shows its real effect on the total.

How much to offer on a house that needs work

A house that needs work is worth what it is worth in its current condition, not once it is finished. The offer has to leave room for the work, the risk and the time it takes.

  1. Find out what the work is. Viewings tell you some of it; a survey tells you more. Our house survey checklist covers what to look at before you commit.
  2. Price it. Rough figures first, then quotes for the big items: roof, structure, damp, electrics, plumbing, heating. Our guide to how much it costs to renovate a house gives published ranges and a method.
  3. Add a contingency. Old houses hide problems. The HomeOwners Alliance suggests setting aside around 10% of the total for unexpected costs, and an abandoned property can need more.
  4. Add the cost of time. Rent, travel or a second set of bills while the house is not habitable.
  5. Compare with finished homes. Sold prices of similar homes in good condition, less your total for the work, contingency and time, give a sense of what the house is worth to you now.
  6. Check the asking price first. If the price is already low because of the condition, deducting the full cost of the work again may produce an offer the seller will not take seriously.
  7. Explain your figure. Share the survey findings or quotes that support it.

With an older house, price the roof, structure, damp and services before anything cosmetic, as our guide to renovating an old house explains, and be sure you want a house that needs this much work before you offer; our guide to buying a fixer-upper sets out the questions to ask.

Tip

The work you would like to do and the work the house needs are different lists. Base your offer on the work it needs. The extension, the new kitchen and the garden room are your choices, not the seller's problem.

How to make an offer on a house

The HomeOwners Alliance suggests telling the estate agent and confirming in writing. Include:

  • The amount you are offering
  • Your buying position: first-time buyer, chain-free, or a home to sell
  • How you are paying for it, and the evidence you can show
  • Your preferred timescale and how flexible you can be
  • Whether you have a solicitor or conveyancer lined up
  • Any conditions, such as a satisfactory survey or items included in the sale

Ask the agent to confirm the offer has been passed to the seller. If your offer is accepted, ask for that in writing and ask whether the property will be taken off the market. Our buying a house checklist takes you through every step from offer to keys.

Negotiating after your first offer

  • Do not reveal your maximum. The HomeOwners Alliance advises showing interest without saying how much you can pay or how quickly you need to move.
  • Move in steps, with reasons. Each increase is easier to justify if it is tied to evidence.
  • Know when to stop. When the price passes your maximum, walking away is part of the plan, not a failure.

Country rules

How offers work, and when they become binding, differs between countries. These are the main differences; check the official guidance where you are buying.

In England and Wales

Citizens Advice says a written offer is always made subject to contract. Either side can still withdraw until contracts are exchanged, which is also why a buyer can ask to renegotiate after the survey. Sold prices can be searched on GOV.UK.

In Scotland

Citizens Advice Scotland says an offer should include a brief description of the home, the price and your preferred date of entry, and it is made through a solicitor. Once a binding contract (the missives) is agreed between the solicitors, neither side can withdraw or change the terms without the other's agreement.

Elsewhere

In some countries an early offer, a reservation or a deposit can bind you sooner than in England. Before you sign or pay anything, ask an independent local professional what you are committing to. Our guide to buying a house in Spain covers one example.

On the Operation Sicily villa

From the villa in Sicily. Before buying his villa in western Sicily, Jonathan Smith, Mekozo's founder, viewed about 50 properties over three months and walked away from two deals when the documents and plans revealed problems (Episode 8). The villa he bought had been advertised at €100,000 and had been on the market for five years. He paid €21,500, as he explains on Operation Sicily, where he films the renovation, with €1,500 for the notary, €1,500 for the estate agent and €4,500 in taxes on top: €29,000 in all (Episode 9). The gap between the asking price and the price paid shows how little an asking price can tell you about a house that has sat unsold and needs everything doing. His cost breakdown is clear that the purchase price was the starting point, not the project budget, which is why the cost of the work belongs in the offer from the start.

Playing loads YouTube’s external player.

Watch directly on YouTube ↗

Offer checklist

  • Sold prices of similar homes checked
  • Time on the market and any price reductions noted
  • Condition assessed, and the essential work listed
  • Work priced, with a contingency and the cost of time added
  • Every buying and moving cost included
  • Maximum offer set before speaking to the agent
  • Offer explained with evidence
  • Offer confirmed in writing, with your position and conditions
  • Acceptance confirmed in writing
  • Survey booked, and a plan for what you will do if it finds something new

For the wider journey, see our guide to buying a home, step by step and how long it takes to buy a house. Mekozo lets you compare properties against the full cost before you test a price; see how to build a whole-project budget that includes every buying cost and the work.

This guide explains a method for deciding an offer. It is not legal, financial or valuation advice; check the rules where you are buying and take independent advice before you commit.

Questions people ask

How much should I offer on a house?

There is no fixed percentage. Base your offer on sold prices for similar homes nearby, the property's condition, how long it has been for sale and how much demand there is. The HomeOwners Alliance says an opening offer 5% to 10% below the asking price may be reasonable in a buyer-friendly market, but some homes justify an offer close to the asking price.

How much should I offer on a house that needs work?

Work out what the house is worth in its current condition, not what it will be worth once finished. Price the work from a survey and written quotes, add a contingency and the costs of buying, and compare the total with sold prices of similar finished homes. Check whether the asking price already reflects the work before you deduct it.

Is it rude to offer below the asking price?

No. The HomeOwners Alliance quotes a former RICS Residential Chair who calls the asking price an aspirational starting price that does not necessarily reflect what a property is worth. A low offer works better when you explain it with evidence, such as recent sales or the cost of work; a very low offer without evidence can put the seller off.

How do I make an offer on a house?

Tell the estate agent, then confirm it in writing by email with the amount, your buying position, your timescale and any conditions. Ask the agent to confirm the offer has been passed to the seller. Keep a copy, and note any conditions such as a satisfactory survey.

Can I lower my offer after the survey?

In England and Wales an accepted offer is not binding until contracts are exchanged, so you can ask to renegotiate if the survey finds something you did not know about. Back the request with the survey findings and quotes for the work. The seller can refuse, so decide in advance what you will do if they do.

Is an accepted offer legally binding?

Not in England and Wales: Citizens Advice says a written offer is always made subject to contract, and the sale becomes binding at exchange. In Scotland the offer is made through a solicitor and becomes binding once missives are concluded. Other countries differ, and in some an early offer or deposit can be binding, so check before you sign anything.

Sources

  1. HomeOwners Alliance, How to make an offer on a house and negotiate effectively · 12 November 2026
  2. GOV.UK, Search house price data (HM Land Registry) · Checked 18 November 2026
  3. Citizens Advice, Buying a home (England) · Checked 18 November 2026
  4. Citizens Advice Scotland, Buying a home · Checked 18 November 2026
  5. HomeOwners Alliance, UK house renovation costs · 4 September 2026
  6. Operation Sicily, Episode 9: How much I paid for my villa in Sicily · Checked 18 November 2026
  7. Operation Sicily, Episode 8: Why I bought a villa in Trapani, Sicily · Checked 18 November 2026
  8. Operation Sicily, How much does it really cost to renovate a house in Sicily? (2026 real-world breakdown) · 2026, checked 18 November 2026
Jonathan Smith opening the gate of the villa in Sicily

About the author:

Jonathan Smith is the founder of Mekozo and Operation Sicily. Jonathan bought an abandoned villa in Sicily and is rebuilding it on camera, every week. Mekozo is the app Jonathan built to keep that renovation's money in one picture.

Related from Operation SicilyEpisode 9: How much I paid for my villa in Sicily

Real renovation experience and regional guidance from Operation Sicily.

Blog

Related reading

A run-down room with peeling paint, a broken window and a hole in the wall
Choosing a property

Buying a fixer-upper: the real cost before you offer

A house that needs work is only a bargain if the price reflects the work. A step-by-step method to price a fixer-upper before you offer, what to check first and how to decide whether to buy, renovate or walk away.

All Blog posts →

Bring the whole picture home.

Budgets, quotes, payments, documents and decisions in one place

30 days free. No card needed.

Monthly, with no annual plan. The Terms of membership set out the details.