Planning a renovation

What a good builder's quote includes, line by line

What a good builder's quote includes, what to ask every builder to send back, and how to compare quotes like for like rather than by the total.

What a quote covers: strip out and new plaster included, skip hire and making good not included
Contents

Key points

  • A good builder's quote is a fixed price for a clearly described job, with the work and materials broken into separate costs.
  • It should say what is excluded, whether VAT is included, how long the price is valid, the payment stages and when the price can change.
  • A quote is a fixed price; an estimate is a rough guess that can change.
  • To compare builder quotes fairly, send every builder the same written scope with numbered items, then compare item by item, not by the total.
  • The cheapest headline figure is often the quote with the most unanswered questions.

A good builder's quote is a fixed price for a clearly described job. It splits work and materials into separate costs, says what is excluded, whether VAT is included, how long the price is valid and the payment stages. To compare quotes fairly, send every builder the same numbered scope, then compare item by item, not by the total.

The cheapest headline figure is often the one with the most unanswered questions. This guide shows what to ask every builder to send back, a checklist for what comes back, and a step by step comparison method.

Quote or estimate: know which one you have

The words matter. According to Citizens Advice's guidance before you get work done on your home, a quote is a fixed price, while an estimate is just a rough guess, so you might end up paying more.

Under a quote, Citizens Advice says the trader cannot charge you more than the quoted price unless:

  • you ask for extra work that is not included in the quote;
  • they tell you they need to do extra work and you agree to pay more for it; or
  • they made a genuine mistake when writing down or calculating the price.

Citizens Advice also notes that once you say yes to a quote, it is a binding agreement, whether it is written down or not, and recommends getting it in writing so you can prove what was agreed.

In the UK

The rules above are from Citizens Advice's guidance for England, with separate pages for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. Consumer rights differ in other countries, so check the official consumer body where the work is being done.

What a good builder's quote includes

Citizens Advice lists what a quote should contain: a fixed total price (not a daily rate), a breakdown of all the work and materials, separate costs for each material and part of the work, how long the price is valid for, whether it includes VAT, and when the price can go up. To make quotes truly comparable, add the rest of this checklist.

The price

  • Fixed total price, with VAT shown
  • Separate prices for each item or stage
  • Any provisional sums or allowances, clearly labelled
  • How long the price is valid

The work

  • Description that matches your scope, item by item
  • Materials and finishes named, or allowances stated
  • What is excluded
  • Assumptions (for example "assumes existing joists are sound")
  • Who removes waste, and who pays for skips

The terms

  • Start date and expected finish date
  • Payment stages and what triggers each one
  • How changes and extras will be priced and agreed
  • Guarantees on work and materials
  • Insurance held, such as public liability

The paperwork at the end

  • Certificates you will receive, such as electrical or building control sign-off

Watch out

A daily rate is not a quote. If you are offered one, Citizens Advice suggests getting in writing how many days the work will take, how many hours count as a day and when the trader needs your go-ahead to work more days.

What to ask every builder to send back

Ask every builder to price your scope of works in the same layout, so each one returns the same information. If you do not have a written scope yet, start with our guide to writing a scope of works.

Scope item no.DescriptionLabourMaterialsItem totalIncluded? Notes
4.1
4.2
4.3
Provisional sums
Exclusions
Total (excluding VAT)
VAT
Total (including VAT)

Then ask each builder to answer these in writing:

  1. How long is this price valid?
  2. What are the payment stages, and what work triggers each one?
  3. How will you price and confirm any change before doing it?
  4. What is your earliest start date and expected finish date?
  5. What insurance do you hold? Please send a copy.
  6. What guarantees come with the work and the materials?
  7. What certificates will I receive at the end?
  8. Is there anything in the scope you would do differently, and why?

How many quotes, and from whom

At least three written quotes, on the same scope, is the usual advice: RICS's guide to home extensions and improvements recommends at least three detailed quotes. Citizens Advice notes that some contractors charge for quotes, so ask about this first. Our guide to how to find a good builder covers who to ask and the checks to make before you invite them.

How to compare builder quotes like for like

Two quotes for the same kitchen in Mekozo, close up: £5,500 accepted and £6,200 received, each with what it includes and excludes

Mekozo lines builders' quotes up side by side, with what each includes and excludes and its timing, so you compare like for like and can see what each one leaves out.

Try it free for 30 days, no card needed
  1. Line the quotes up by item number. Put every builder's price for item 4.1 in one row, 4.2 in the next, and so on.
  2. Mark gaps and exclusions. If one builder has excluded something another has included, note it in that row.
  3. Price the gaps. For each exclusion, add your best estimate of what it will cost you separately, so every total covers the same job.
  4. Separate fixed prices from allowances. A provisional sum is a placeholder, not a price. Two quotes with very different allowances are not comparable until you level them.
  5. Compare the adjusted totals. Now you are comparing like for like.
  6. Compare the terms, not just the money. Payment stages, programme, insurance, guarantees and how changes are handled.
  7. Ask about the outliers. If one item is far higher or lower than the others, ask why. Citizens Advice warns that a price a lot lower than other quotes could mean the trader is not quoting for exactly the same work.

Here is how a levelled comparison looks:

ItemBuilder ABuilder BBuilder C
4.1 Strip out£800£650£900
4.2 First fix£2,400£2,100£2,600
4.3 Tiling£1,900Excluded£1,750
Gap priced by you+£1,800 (your estimate)
Waste removalIncluded£350 extraIncluded
Adjusted total£5,100£4,900£5,250
Deposit asked10%30%None
Start4 weeks2 weeks10 weeks

Illustrative figures only.

Builder B's headline looked cheapest by far. Once the excluded tiling and the waste removal are added, the gap shrinks to a few hundred pounds, and the 30% deposit is above the 25% ceiling Citizens Advice suggests not exceeding. That is a very different decision from the one the totals suggested.

Tip

Keep a single list of questions per builder. When you ring them, you can work through it and note the answers against their quote, rather than relying on memory.

Red flags in a builder's quote

  • No written quote, or a price given only verbally.
  • A lump sum with no breakdown.
  • A daily rate with no number of days.
  • Large upfront payments or cash only. Citizens Advice advises against traders who only accept cash or want everything upfront.
  • No mention of insurance, guarantees or certificates.
  • Vague phrases such as "as required" or "allow for" with no figure.
  • Pressure to decide quickly.

Agree how payments and changes will work

The quote is also where you set the rules for money. Citizens Advice suggests paying by card rather than cash, paying in stages, avoiding deposits where you can and, if one is unavoidable, not agreeing to more than 25%. RICS suggests agreeing a method for making changes before work begins, and holding back 5% to be released on satisfactory completion.

In the UK

Citizens Advice notes that if you pay for work costing between £100.01 and £30,000 by credit card, you may be able to make a section 75 claim against the card provider if something goes wrong, including on a deposit paid by credit card.

Once a quote is agreed, tie each payment to a stage you can check, as our guide to how to pay a contractor explains, and price any variation or extra (change order) before it goes ahead, as our guide to variations and extras shows.

On the Operation Sicily villa

From the villa in Sicily. For the new windows and doors at his villa, Mekozo's founder, Jonathan Smith, contacted window companies across Italy, Poland and Germany. Along the way he changed a lot of details, from colours and glass to handles and opening directions, and he says price mattered but was not the deal-breaker, as he explains in Episode 88 of Operation Sicily, where he films the renovation. Each change to the specification is a reason to make sure every supplier is quoting for the same thing. For plastering, he went further and marked the scope on the building itself, spraying green crosses on every wall and ceiling to be skimmed so the plasterers could see exactly what to price (Episode 29). His real-world breakdown of renovation costs in Sicily has a section on comparing labour quotes for the complete job.

Playing loads YouTube’s external player.

Watch directly on YouTube ↗

Before you say yes

  • Every quote prices the same scope, with gaps priced.
  • Exclusions and assumptions are listed.
  • Payment stages and change rules are agreed in writing.
  • Insurance and guarantees are checked.
  • The quote, the scope and your questions and answers are kept together.

For the wider planning stage, see our guide to how to plan a renovation, from scope to quotes and budget, our guide to how much contingency to allow, the line-by-line kitchen renovation budget as an example of a fully broken-down price, and Mekozo's own guide to comparing quotes. When you have agreed a price, the renovation budget tracker shows how to keep it apart from what you have paid.

This guide explains a method for comparing quotes. It is not legal advice; for a dispute or a contract question, contact Citizens Advice or a qualified adviser.

Questions people ask

What should a builder's quote include?

Citizens Advice says a quote should include a fixed total price rather than a daily rate, a breakdown of the work and materials, separate costs for each part, how long the price is valid, whether it includes VAT and when the price can go up. Add exclusions, payment stages, start and finish dates and the certificates you will receive.

What is the difference between a quote and an estimate?

A quote is a fixed price for the work described; an estimate is a rough guess, so you might end up paying more. Under a quote, Citizens Advice says the trader cannot charge more unless you ask for extra work, agree to pay for extra work they tell you about, or there was a genuine mistake in the price.

How many quotes should I get from builders?

At least three written quotes, Citizens Advice and RICS both suggest. More quotes only help if each one prices the same written scope.

How do I compare builder quotes fairly?

Send every builder the same numbered scope, ask them to price against your item numbers, and line the quotes up item by item. List each quote's exclusions and assumptions, add a price for anything missing, and compare the adjusted totals along with payment terms, programme and insurance.

Should I choose the cheapest builder's quote?

Not automatically. Citizens Advice warns that a price much lower than the others might mean the trader is not quoting for exactly the same work, and RICS advises against automatically accepting the cheapest quote. Compare what each price includes before comparing the numbers.

Do builders charge for quotes?

Some do, Citizens Advice notes, so ask before anyone visits. A free quote is still worth having in writing, priced against your scope.

Sources

  1. Citizens Advice, Before you get work done on your home (England) · Checked 18 November 2026
  2. Citizens Advice, Problem with building work, decorating or home improvements · Checked 18 November 2026
  3. Citizens Advice Scotland, Before you get building work done · Checked 18 November 2026
  4. RICS, Home extensions and improvements consumer guide · Published 8 April 2022, checked 18 November 2026
  5. Operation Sicily, Episode 88: New windows and doors fitted at my Sicilian villa · Checked 18 November 2026
  6. Operation Sicily, Episode 29: Marking walls for plaster quotes · Checked 18 November 2026
Jonathan Smith opening the gate of the villa in Sicily

About the author:

Jonathan Smith is the founder of Mekozo and Operation Sicily. Jonathan bought an abandoned villa in Sicily and is rebuilding it on camera, every week. Mekozo is the app Jonathan built to keep that renovation's money in one picture.

Related from Operation SicilyHow much does it really cost to renovate a house in Sicily? (2026)

Real renovation experience and regional guidance from Operation Sicily.

Blog

Related reading

A renovation budget by room: kitchen, bathroom, rewiring and one job not priced yet
Planning a renovation

Home renovation budget: how to set one, step by step

A home renovation budget is a spending limit, a scope and a list of every cost, with a contingency on top. Eight steps to set one, the lines people miss, and how to keep it honest once work starts.

All Blog posts →

Bring the whole picture home.

Budgets, quotes, payments, documents and decisions in one place

30 days free. No card needed.

Monthly, with no annual plan. The Terms of membership set out the details.