Choosing a property

How to compare houses you have viewed

Score every house against the same wish list, put the full cost beside it, and make the trade-off visible before you offer.

A farmhouse and a town flat scored side by side on space, shops nearby and garden
Contents

Key points

  • Compare houses against one written wish list, scoring every house the same way, rather than from memory.
  • Put the full cost beside each house: the price, the buying costs, the work it needs and what it costs to run.
  • Mark anything you do not know as unknown, never as zero.
  • Write one sentence on the biggest compromise each house asks of you; that is usually where the real decision sits.
  • Do not rewrite your wish list to fit a favourite house after a viewing.

To compare houses you have viewed, score each one against the same written wish list, then put the full cost beside it: the price, the buying costs, the work it needs and the running costs. Mark anything you do not know as unknown, never as zero. Then write one sentence on the biggest compromise each house asks of you.

That sentence is usually where the real decision sits.

Comparing on price and number of bedrooms alone hides the reasons the choice feels hard. One house has the garden, another is ten minutes closer to the people you see every week, a third needs far less work. A consistent method lets you see those trade-offs plainly.

Why comparing houses from memory goes wrong

After a run of viewings, memory is a poor judge. The last house you saw feels clearer than the first. A sunny afternoon flatters one property, a wet Tuesday spoils another. And a single feature you love, a view or a fireplace, can quietly outweigh three things you need.

A written comparison fixes three common problems:

  • Moving goalposts. You judge each house against the one before rather than against what you need.
  • Hidden costs. A cheaper house that needs a new roof can cost more than a dearer one that does not.
  • Gaps treated as good news. An unanswered question feels like no problem until it is one.

Step 1: write your wish list before you compare

Everything else depends on a short, written list of what you need. Split it in two.

  • Must-haves: the things that make everyday life work. If a house fails one, it is out. Keep this list short, usually five to eight items.
  • Nice-to-haves: the things that would make life better but that you could live without or add later.

Our guide to building a house wish list covers how to separate the two, and how to agree them if you are buying with someone else.

Tip

Write must-haves as tests, not wishes. "Two bedrooms of at least double size" is easier to check than "enough space". "Under 30 minutes to work at 8am" is easier to check than "good commute".

Step 2: score every house the same way

Go through your viewing notes for each house and score it against the list.

  • Must-haves: pass, fail or unknown. A fail drops the house from the shortlist.
  • Nice-to-haves: a simple score, such as 0 (no), 1 (partly) or 2 (yes).
  • Optional weighting: if some nice-to-haves matter more, multiply by 1, 2 or 3. Keep it simple; a score that takes an hour to calculate hides more than it shows.

If you have not recorded viewings consistently, our guide to questions to ask when viewing a house has a checklist that makes this step quicker.

Step 3: add the full cost of each house

The asking price is only the start. For each house, add:

Cost lineWhat to include
PriceAsking price, or your likely offer
Buying costsTax on the purchase, legal fees, survey, lender fees if borrowing, removals
Work neededRepairs and changes to make it work for you, even as rough estimates
Running costsEnergy, water, local property tax, service charges, insurance
Living costs during workRent or a second home while work happens, if you cannot live there

Buying costs alone can be substantial. In its May 2026 guide, Which? put average conveyancing at £1,421 and a house survey at £462 for first-time buyers, and £2,182 and £510 for home movers. Our full guide to the costs of buying a house lists every line.

In the UK

You can check a property's council tax band in England or Wales with GOV.UK's Council Tax band checker, find its energy rating with Find an energy certificate, and check flood risk in England with the long term flood risk service. Use the same checks for every house on your shortlist so the comparison stays fair.

Watch out

A house that needs work is not cheaper until you know what the work costs. If you are weighing a project, our guide to buying a fixer-upper shows how to price it before you offer.

Step 4: put the houses side by side

Two example properties compared against a three-bedroom brief: one matches, one has a recorded compromise

Mekozo compares the homes you are considering side by side against your Property Brief, showing which points each one meets, which it misses, and its price.

Try it free for 30 days, no card needed

Now line them up. A simple comparison looks like this:

House AHouse BHouse C
Must-haves met6 of 65 of 6 (1 unknown)6 of 6
Nice-to-have score7119
Price£285,000£270,000£299,000
Buying costsKnownKnownKnown
Work neededSmallNew kitchen, rewireDecorating
Yearly running costsLowerHigher (older boiler)Middle
Open questions142
Biggest compromiseNo gardenUnknown wiring cost15 minutes further from family

Illustrative figures only.

Look at three things together, not one at a time:

  1. The must-have line. Any "unknown" needs answering before an offer.
  2. The full cost. Price plus everything else, not price alone.
  3. The biggest compromise. This is the line people skip and later regret.

Step 5: test the compromise, not just the score

Scores help, but they do not decide for you. The useful question is: which compromise can you live with for the next five or ten years?

  • Say it out loud. "We would have no garden." "We would spend our first year on a rewire." "We would be further from your parents." Hearing it plainly helps.
  • Test it in real life. Drive the commute at rush hour. Walk to the shops. Visit after dark.
  • Check it with everyone buying. Couples often weigh the same compromise very differently, and it is better to find out now.

Step 6: watch for changing your list to fit a favourite

After a viewing, it is normal to learn something about what you want. A revised list can be a better list. But notice when you are changing a must-have only to justify a house you have fallen for.

A useful check: would you have changed the list if you had not seen this particular house? If not, keep the original rule, or change it on purpose and apply it to every house, not just the favourite.

Comparing houses when you are buying with someone else

Two people can view the same house and come away with different scores. That is useful information, not a problem, as long as you find it before the offer rather than after.

  1. Agree the must-haves together first. If one of you cannot live without a garden and the other without a short commute, both go on the list.
  2. Score separately, then compare. Each of you scores every house on your own. Where your scores differ by a lot, talk about why.
  3. Share one set of notes and costs. Disagreements are much easier to settle when you are looking at the same facts, not two memories.
  4. Name the deal-breakers out loud. A compromise one of you accepts reluctantly tends to come back later.

Tip

If you are buying with family, such as helping a parent move or buying a home together with siblings, write down who is deciding what. A shared list avoids the decision drifting to whoever went to the most viewings.

Clear the unknowns before you offer

An "unknown" on your shortlist is a question with a deadline. Before you offer on a house, try to turn each one into a fact:

  • Ask the agent in writing for anything the seller should know, such as the age of the boiler or past work.
  • Book a second viewing to check what you could not judge the first time.
  • Get rough prices for any work you would need, so the full cost line is filled in.
  • Note what only a survey can answer, and plan to book one once your offer is accepted.

If a must-have is still unknown when you are ready to offer, decide whether you are comfortable offering subject to finding out, or whether to wait.

Spreadsheet or app?

A house comparison spreadsheet works well if you keep it up to date and use the same columns for every property. It gets harder when you are buying with someone else, when costs change after a survey, or when the notes, photos and questions for each house live somewhere else. Whatever you use, the method is the same: one wish list, one full cost, one compromise per house. Our guide to choosing a house hunting app or spreadsheet compares the two honestly.

On the Operation Sicily villa

From the villa in Sicily. Before buying his villa, Jonathan Smith, Mekozo's founder, who films his villa renovation on Operation Sicily, wrote his criteria down: a detached house with a garden, at least two bedrooms, in a quiet spot near the sea, for under €100,000, that had been on the market a while and needed a complete renovation, with the potential to add value (Episode 8). Over three months and 50 viewings, those criteria were the constant. He walked away from two deals when the documents and plans revealed problems the rooms did not. The villa he chose, in the Trapani province, met the brief, came in under budget and under market value, and had a walled garden for privacy. A fixed list is what made 50 viewings comparable.

Playing loads YouTube’s external player.

Watch directly on YouTube ↗

For buyers abroad, Jonathan's guide to the biggest red flags when buying property in Sicily shows the paperwork checks that belong in any comparison.

Your next step

For your top two houses, write one sentence about the biggest compromise each would require, and put the full cost beside it. Talk through both with anyone you are buying with before deciding which trade-off you can live with. When you are ready, our guide to viewing, shortlisting and choosing a home covers the next steps, and you can see how Mekozo helps you compare properties against your Property Brief, with homes side by side on their full cost.

This guide explains a method for comparing homes. It is not survey, legal or financial advice; use a qualified surveyor and a solicitor or conveyancer before you commit to a purchase.

Questions people ask

How do you compare two houses?

Score both against the same written wish list, split into must-haves and nice-to-haves, and add the full cost of each: price, buying costs, work needed and running costs. Then write one sentence on the biggest compromise each house asks of you. The house with the better score and a compromise you can live with is usually the stronger choice.

What should I include in a house comparison spreadsheet?

Include one row per house with the asking price, buying costs, estimated work, yearly running costs, a column for each must-have and nice-to-have, and a column for open questions. Keep unknowns marked as unknown rather than zero, so a gap never makes a house look cheaper than it is.

Should I weight my priorities when comparing houses?

Weighting helps when you have several nice-to-haves that matter by different amounts. Keep must-haves as pass or fail, and give nice-to-haves a simple weight such as 1 to 3. Avoid weighting so finely that the score hides the real trade-off.

What if I love a house that scores lower?

Write down exactly what you love about it and check whether it is on your wish list. If it is not, decide whether your list was missing something or whether the feeling is covering a compromise. Changing a must-have to fit a favourite is a decision worth making deliberately, not by accident.

How many houses should I compare at once?

A shortlist of two to four is usually enough to compare in detail. Drop any house that fails a must-have, then compare the rest side by side on score, full cost and open questions.

Sources

  1. GOV.UK, Check your Council Tax band · Page updated 9 November 2026, checked 18 November 2026
  2. GOV.UK, Find an energy certificate · Checked 18 November 2026
  3. GOV.UK, Check the long term flood risk for an area in England · Page updated 9 September 2026, checked 18 November 2026
  4. Which?, The cost of buying a house · 28 May 2026
  5. Operation Sicily, Episode 8: Why I bought a villa in Trapani, Sicily (50 viewings) · Checked 18 November 2026
Jonathan Smith opening the gate of the villa in Sicily

About the author:

Jonathan Smith is the founder of Mekozo and Operation Sicily. Jonathan bought an abandoned villa in Sicily and is rebuilding it on camera, every week. Mekozo is the app Jonathan built to keep that renovation's money in one picture.

Related from Operation SicilyThe biggest red flags when buying property in Sicily: what to know before you commit

Real renovation experience and regional guidance from Operation Sicily.

Blog

Related reading

A house hunting checklist: damp and cracks, roof and boiler ticked, noise at night still to check
Choosing a property

House hunting checklist: from first search to an offer

Every step of a house hunt in order, from setting the whole-project budget and writing a wish list to viewings, comparisons and the checks to make before you offer, as one checklist you can work through.

All Blog posts →

Bring the whole picture home.

Budgets, quotes, payments, documents and decisions in one place

30 days free. No card needed.

Monthly, with no annual plan. The Terms of membership set out the details.